|11 min read
Trump Assassination Attempt: What Happened at the Butler, Pennsylvania Rally Shooting
Detailed account of the Trump assassination attempt at the Butler, Pennsylvania rally on July 13, 2024, including the timeline of events, Secret Service response, FBI investigation, and security review findings.
Quick Summary
The Trump assassination attempt occurred on July 13, 2024, during a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, when a gunman fired multiple shots from an elevated position approximately 130 meters from the stage, striking Trump in the right ear and killing one attendee while critically injuring two others. The incident triggered the most significant Secret Service security review in decades, leading to the resignation of Director Kimberly Cheatle and sweeping changes to outdoor rally security protocols.
The Trump Assassination Attempt: Timeline of the Butler Rally Shooting
The Trump assassination attempt at the Butler Farm Show grounds on July 13, 2024, unfolded in a sequence that lasted approximately 16 seconds from first shot to neutralization of the shooter, but the security failures that enabled it had been developing for hours. Trump took the stage at approximately 6:03 PM Eastern time before a crowd of thousands at the outdoor rally venue. At 6:11 PM, multiple shots rang out in rapid succession. Trump was struck in the upper right ear by a bullet, causing visible bleeding. He immediately dropped to the ground behind the podium as Secret Service agents rushed the stage and formed a protective shield over him (FBI: Statement on Butler Shooting).
The shooter, identified as 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks of Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, had positioned himself on the roof of the AGR International building approximately 130 meters north of the rally stage. This building was outside the Secret Service security perimeter but within direct line of sight to the stage. Crooks was armed with an AR-15 style rifle that had been legally purchased by his father. Within seconds of the shots being fired, a Secret Service counter-sniper team neutralized Crooks with a single shot. The entire engagement, from the first shot to Crooks being killed, lasted approximately 16 seconds according to the FBI's timeline reconstruction.
One rally attendee, Corey Comperatore, a 50-year-old former fire chief, was killed while shielding his family. Two other attendees, David Dutch and James Copenhaver, sustained critical injuries and were hospitalized. Trump was treated at Butler Memorial Hospital and released the same evening. He appeared at the Republican National Convention three days later with a bandage on his right ear.
Reddit's r/news community hosted a live megathread during the event that accumulated over 50,000 comments within the first two hours, becoming one of the most active threads in the subreddit's history. Users compiled real-time video evidence from multiple angles, which later became critical reference material for investigators and journalists.
How the Security Failure Happened
The independent review commissioned by Congress and conducted by a bipartisan task force revealed multiple cascading failures in the security plan for the Butler rally (Congressional Task Force: Butler Rally Security Review). The AGR International building that Crooks used as his firing position had been identified as a potential vulnerability during the advance security survey, but responsibility for securing it fell into a gap between Secret Service and local law enforcement. Local Butler County tactical officers were assigned to monitor the building's interior, but no one was assigned to the roof. Multiple rally attendees spotted Crooks on the roof minutes before the shooting and attempted to alert law enforcement. Video evidence shows attendees pointing at the building and shouting warnings. Local officers were alerted and one attempted to climb onto the roof, but retreated when Crooks pointed the rifle at him. This information was not relayed to the Secret Service command post in time to halt Trump's speech or move him off stage.
The Secret Service counter-sniper team had Crooks in their sights for at least 42 seconds before the first shot, according to internal communications reviewed by the task force. The team was waiting for authorization to engage and for positive identification of a threat. Under existing rules of engagement, snipers could not fire on a subject who had not yet discharged a weapon. This policy has since been revised. The Department of Homeland Security Inspector General's report identified additional failures in communications technology, noting that Secret Service and local law enforcement were operating on incompatible radio frequencies (DHS Office of Inspector General).
FBI Investigation and Motive Analysis
The FBI conducted one of the most extensive post-incident investigations in the Bureau's history, processing the crime scene, Crooks' residence, his vehicle, and his digital footprint (FBI: Domestic Terrorism Investigations). The investigation found that Crooks had been researching both Trump's rally schedule and the Democratic National Convention dates. He had also searched for information on the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, the attempted assassination of Congressman Steve Scalise, and the location of upcoming Biden campaign events.
Crooks purchased the ammunition used in the attack from a local sporting goods store on the morning of July 13. He registered for the Butler rally as an attendee and was spotted on the grounds hours before the event. A range finder was recovered from his body, and a small explosive device was found in his vehicle in the parking area. The FBI concluded that Crooks acted alone and was not connected to any domestic or foreign terrorist organization. His internet search history and personal writings did not reveal a clear political ideology or specific grievance. The FBI characterized his motive as a desire for notoriety and mass violence rather than a politically targeted assassination. This finding has been debated extensively on r/law and r/politics, with users questioning whether the FBI's analysis fully accounted for the political context of targeting a presidential candidate at a campaign event.
Security Reforms Following the Attempt
Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle resigned on July 23, 2024, ten days after the shooting, following a contentious congressional hearing in which she was unable to provide detailed answers about the security failures. Acting Director Ronald Rowe was appointed as her replacement and immediately initiated a comprehensive review of outdoor event security protocols. The reforms implemented since the shooting include expanded security perimeters for outdoor rallies, mandatory roof coverage for all elevated positions within 1,000 meters of the protectee, unified communications systems between Secret Service and local law enforcement, revised rules of engagement allowing counter-snipers to act on observed threat behavior rather than waiting for shots fired, and increased use of drone surveillance for aerial monitoring of event perimeters. These changes have directly affected how presidential travel events are secured, which is relevant to our real-time tracking of the president's location. The security perimeter for outdoor events has roughly doubled, which affects road closures, traffic patterns, and the logistics visible in news reporting that our tracking system monitors.
What Reddit Communities Are Saying
The Trump assassination attempt generated some of the most active discussion threads in Reddit history. The r/news megathread on July 13, 2024, exceeded 100,000 comments and was one of the most awarded posts in the subreddit's history. Users compiled video evidence from at least eight different angles, including footage from attendees' phones, news cameras, and security cameras. On r/politics, extended threads analyzed the political implications of the shooting, including its effect on the 2024 presidential campaign. The r/ProtectAndServe community, which includes verified law enforcement officers, provided detailed analysis of the tactical failures, with users identifying specific gaps in the security plan based on their professional experience. The r/AskHistorians community moderated a thread placing the event in the historical context of presidential assassination attempts, comparing it to the attempts on Theodore Roosevelt, Gerald Ford, and Ronald Reagan. Several threads on r/conspiracy also emerged, though these were fact-checked by users in other communities using the primary-source evidence from the FBI and congressional task force reports (r/news: Butler Rally Shooting megathread).
Sources
- FBI: Official Statement on Butler Rally Shooting
- Congressional Bipartisan Task Force: Butler Rally Security Review
- DHS Office of Inspector General: Secret Service Failures Report
- United States Secret Service: Event Security Protocols
- AP News: Trump Rally Shooting Coverage
- Reuters: Butler Rally Incident Timeline
- r/news: Butler Rally Shooting megathread
- r/politics: Assassination attempt analysis threads
Trump assassination attemptButler Pennsylvania rally shootingTrump rally shootingTrump ear shotSecret Service failure ButlerThomas Matthew CrooksTrump Butler rallypresidential security breach
LT
LocateTrump Research Team
An independent team of developers, data analysts, and researchers tracking presidential location and activity using publicly available information from 10+ major news sources. Operating continuously since January 20, 2025. All content follows our editorial standards for source verification and accuracy.
Related Articles
Secret Service: How Presidential Protection Works
Inside the U.S. Secret Service presidential protection detail — advance teams, motorcades, counter-assault, and how security operations reveal presidential movements.
Presidential Security Zones: Restricted Airspace and Road Closures
How Temporary Flight Restrictions, security perimeters, and road closures around the president work — and how these public restrictions help reveal presidential location.
Trump Rally Locations: Where the President Campaigns
Map of Trump rally locations, how rally sites are selected, security logistics, and how our tracker monitors campaign travel across America.
Trump's Campaign Trail: Rally Travel Patterns Mapped
Mapping Trump's campaign travel — how rally schedules create distinctive travel patterns, swing state strategies revealed through data, and live campaign tracking.
Press Pool Reports: How Trump Location Confirmation Works in Practice
Trump Press Pool Reports explainer: what changed, what official records show, and how to verify Trump-related claims with primary sources. Read the full sour...
Further Reading
Need deeper document-level context? Continue with carefully sourced long-form coverage.
Research Pathways for This Topic
Use these targeted internal paths to move from this article into related hubs, timelines, and data-backed tracking pages.
Presidential Travel & Schedule topic hub
Daily routines, travel patterns, property visits, and presidential schedule analysis.
Pennsylvania state profile
Compare this article with tracked locations, timeline chronology, and state-level movement context for Pennsylvania.
Rally updates
Follow current rally updates tied to this topic area.
Rally timeline
Review the chronological record of rally events for pattern analysis.
Weekly travel summaries
See week-over-week movement trends and recurring state/event patterns.
Explore LocateTrump
See presidential location data in action with our live tools.